|
"To
waste, to destroy our natural resources,
to skin and exhaust the land instead
of using it so as to increase its
usefulness, will result in undermining
in the days of our children the very
prosperity which we ought by right
to hand down to them amplified and
developed".
US
President Theodore Roosevelt
Seventh Annual Message
3rd December 1907
|
|
|
Gulf of Mannar's
Spiritual and Scientific Relevance to the Earth
The Gulf of
Mannar - located on the southeastern tip of
India in the state of Tamil Nadu - is one of
the world's special biodiversity hotspots with
exceptional terrestrial and marine ecosystems.
It is also important culturally, containing
Adam's Bridge, also known as Ram Sethu, which
is a partially submerged isthmus connecting
India to Sri Lanka and is sacred to the Hindu
faith. The Gulf's limestone reefs form an essential
habitat for the fabled Pearl oyster beds, source
of the fabulous treasures of ancient Egypt,
Greece and Rome.
 |
|
Around
3,600 species of fauna and flora have
been identified in the Gulf, which contains
three different ecosystems -- sea grass,
mangrove and coral reef. The shallow waters
in the area have the highest concentration
of sea grass species in India. These meadows
support complex ecological communities
that provide habitat for endangered dugongs
and marine turtles; as well as innumerable
fish, seahorse, molluscs and crustaceans
that also feed here. The sheltered Mannar
Gulf, free from oceanic currents, provides
calving grounds for a substantial part
of the highly diverse whale population
of the Bay of Bengal.
The Gulf
of Mannar is now threatened by the Sethusamudram
Ship Channel Project (SSCP) which will
dig an ocean shipping channel to link
the shallow waters of the Palk Strait
with the Gulf of Mannar. In 2005 the Government
of India approved the multi-million dollar
project, which will dredge the shallow
ocean floor to create enough leeway allowing
ships to pass through the channel instead
of having to go around the island of Sri
Lanka.
|
 |
|
Opponents
of the project express serious concerns
over the flawed Environmental Impact Assessments
that has not taken into account the devastating
impacts to marine life while simultaneously
ignoring critical environmental and humanitarian
issues, including the livelihood of thousands
of fishermen in the region. Were the project
to proceed, it would alter the ecology
of the region, destroy traditional livelihoods
and would challenge the survival of numerous
endangered species.
The
Campaign
A growing number of environmental and
cultural organizations from across the
globe are coming together to promote an
unprecedented international campaign calling
for permanent cancellation of the SSCP
and to have the Gulf of Mannar designated
as a UNESCO World Heritage site. In November
2008, the groups will be meeting for the
"Gulf of Mannar International Meeting"
in London to provide a forum for The Gulf
of Mannar, and formulate a hard hitting,
ambitious campaign for its total protection.
Setting aside the Gulf of Mannar as a
World Heritage Site would preserve in
perpetuity its unique, fragile and diverse
ecosystems, habitats and communities of
flora and fauna, as well as areas of Indian
cultural significance. World Heritage
Site status would provide additional safeguards
for religious and cultural sites and give
a protective buffer around the Gulf of
Mannar, safeguarding the foraging grounds
of the marine life it sustains.
Findings,
conclusions and action plans resulting
from the international meeting will contribute
directly to an effort to designate the
Gulf of Mannar as an UNESCO World Heritage
mixed Natural and Cultural site. Organizers
include Peter Bunyard, UK; Living Planet
Foundation, USA; Rainforest Rescue International
(RRI), Sri Lanka; Both Ends, The Netherlands;
GHRD, The Netherlands; Rainforest Concern,
UK; Ecological Internet, USA; Norwich
International Consultants (NIC), Kingdom
of Bahrain.
|
 |
|
The
Facts
Environmental/Ecological/Marine Life/
Migratory Birds
The Gulf of Mannar is one of the richest
zones of biodiversity in the Indian Ocean
region. The area has a diversity of ecosystems,
species and genes, and habitats. It boasts
large sea grass meadows, an essential
habitat for the endangered Green Turtle
and for the Dugong; Coral islets, that
boast of the highest diversity of coral
fish and sea snakes in the Indian ocean;
and limestone reefs that form the fabled
Pearl oyster beds.
Productive fringing and the patchy coral
reef surrounding the Gulf of Mannar islands
are comprised of at least 91 species of
coral species. This region is also home
to over 450 species of fish, 79 species
of crustaceans, 108 species of sponges,
260 species of mollusks and 100 species
of echinoderms. Eleven species of sea
grass recorded in India are found in the
reserve, three of which are found nowhere
else. The same shallow waters are also
known to have at least 147 species of
marine algae (seaweed).
The sheltered gulf, free from oceanic
currents, forms the calving grounds for
a greater part of the highly diverse whale
population of the Bay of Bengal. It is
the source of the chank fishery that supplies
conches for ritual use through the subcontinent
and Sri Lanka. It also provides much of
northern Sri Lanka and South Eastern India
with its fish. There are serious concerns
that carbon dioxide will be released by
disruption of the Miocene limestone base
and freshwater aquifers that lie within
the region's limestone cavities.
The islands
and the sandbanks in the region are a
regular stopover for migratory birds traveling
between North Indian habitats and Sri
Lanka. Nearly 180 bird types find habitat
or seasonal resting grounds here. Lesser
Sand Piper, Curlew Sandpiper and Little
Stint are found here in abundance. Rare
birds like Red Knot, Eastern Knot, Crab
Plovers, Bar-tailed Godwit, Broad-billed
Sandpiper, Dunlin, Long-toed Stint and
Redneck Phalarope are regular seasonal
visitors. Little Tern, Kentish Plover,
Stone Plover, Stone Curlew, Lesser-crested
Sterna, etc; fly long distances to specifically
come here for breeding. Thousands of Larger
flamingos migrate here to spend winters.
The wetlands and marshes of the region
support highly vulnerable species like
Spoonbill Sandpiper and Grey Pelican both
of which are on the red list of endangered
species.
Adam's Bridge as a Breakwater
Adam's Bridge separates two distinct marine
systems - the Gulf of Mannar and the Palk
Bay - making them almost completely secluded
and nearly isolated, resembling two huge
lagoons, existing side by side. Adam's
Bridge is a chain of limestone shoals,
which appear during low tide as a narrow
ridge of mostly dry sand and rocks that
connects Rameshwaram in Southeastern India
to Talaimannar in Sri Lanka. At high tide
it is covered by about 4 ft (1.2 m) of
water.
By acting as a breakwater, Adam's Bridge
induces a certain stillness and calm to
the Gulf of Mannar. The Gulf of Mannar,
including the Palk Bay and Palk Strait,
is a major sedimentation sink for the
East coast. Indian and Sri Lankan Rivers
and long shore currents bring sedimentation,
which Adam's Bridge causes to sink. This
natural breakwater also forces ocean currents
the longer way around Sri Lanka. Adam's
Bridge's role in circulation of ocean
currents has provided the nutrients that
make the area's remarkable marine ecosystems
possible.
Should Adam's Bridge be breached, the
shallow silted waters of the Palk Bay
will flow into the Gulf of Mannar, destroying
its fragile ecosystem. Breaching Adam's
Bridge would also impact the meadows of
sea grass in Palk Bay, which are home
to a large number of fish species and
the rare dugong or sea cow. Adam's Bridge
has also been a natural barrier to shipping
activity in the region, and therefore
unlike seas anywhere else in the world,
the local marine life has been nearly
untouched by shipping lane impacts. The
opening up of this area as a shipping
corridor will cause many well-established
negative effects on terrestrial and aquatic
systems.
Human
Livelihood
The fishermen of both India and Sri Lanka
stand to lose their livelihood if the
SSCP is allowed to proceed. Hundreds of
fishing villages and thousands of fishermen
depend heavily on the fishery resources
of the Gulf of Mannar for their livelihood.
The lives of the traditional fisher folk,
who are already fighting a losing battle
against the giant commercial fishing industry
that has intruded into their territory
with mechanized equipment, would be completely
disrupted. On the Sri Lankan side, the
war weary people would have another horror
thrust upon their lives, as fertile fishing
grounds would be totally destroyed.
Affects on Agriculture
Sri Lankan scientists point out to the
potential damage dredging could have on
the precious freshwater resources of the
dry Jaffna peninsula. Dredging of Palk
Strait would have a catastrophic effect
on the water table, increasing the salinity
content of the drinking and irrigational
water. This would have a drastic economic
impact destroying the livelihood of many
farmers. These negative impacts would
have a serious effect on the production
of food, and marine products, thereby
impacting the GDP of the country as well
as increasing the unemployment in the
region.
Project Economics
A major aim of the proposed SSCP is to
save ship time, fuel and transport costs.
Critics say that it is unlikely to remain
on budget, because the costs of dredging
(its primary expense) have been grossly
underestimated. The revenues, too, may
be less than the scale that is being projected.
The canal's limited depth will allow only
ships with a draught of 10 meters or less.
This constraint is critical. Revenue from
these ships was supposed to provide two-thirds
of the canal's income. Iff the industry
pushes for deepening the canal it would
become even more economically and environmentally
unviable.
Damage due to Marine Accidents/Cyclones/General
Pollution
Indian Mariners refer to the Tamil Nadu
coast between Rameshwaram and Cuddalore
as the "cyclone coast". The
weather in the region is prone to severe
cyclones and storms and would be highly
conducive to shipping hazards such as
straying, grounding, or collisions resulting
in oil spill disasters. Maritime accidents
due to other causes such as shallowness
or narrowness of the shipping passage,
close proximity of reefs, terrorist attack
and sabotage are distinct possibilities
and pose serious concerns.
The area's marine environment is already
under severe stress due to increasing
number of industries on the coast. Some
of these like the Tuticorin Thermal Power
Station and the Dhrangadhra Chemical and
Tuticorin Salt Marine Chemicals have been
discharging ash and effluents, thus adversely
affecting the sea grasses and coral ecosystems
in the vicinity.
Cultural /Religious Perspective
Adam's Bridge is an ancient monument held
sacred by millions of Hindus around the
world who look upon Adam's Bridge as Ram Sethu
- a sacred symbol of their faith, heritage
and history. Ram Sethu's historical antiquity
goes back several millennia.
Marine archaeological research is demonstrating
the existence of a great number of drowned
cities and temples, suggesting that these
waters overlie the lost land of Kumari
Kandam, the source of much of the literary
and spiritual origins of the people of
the region (more below).
|
 |
|
Defiance
of Global Conventions/Local Laws
The SSCP is being pursued in defiance of
global conventions such as the UNEP/CMS,
Convention on Biological Diversity and Ramsar
Convention on Wetlands. A group of 'developers'
have initiated the Sethusamudram Ship Channel
Project (SSCP) without any public consultation
or reference to neighboring Sri Lanka that
will be affected by the project. Dredging
activity will result in a permanent loss
of corals, sea fans, sponges, pearl oysters,
mollusks and sea cucumbers along the canal,
all of which are protected under the Indian
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972. Corals
are Schedule-I species, which means the
Indian government accords them the same
protected status as tigers.
Security
Concerns
No security analysis was conducted before
the project was launched and the concerns
of the navy and coast guard were not taken
into consideration. The Indian Coast Guard
director believes the channel is a security
risk and the security experts note that
terrorist organizations are allying with
pirates, and turning their attention to
narrow strait channels, where ships are
most vulnerable.
"Terrorists want to attack ships
plying through narrow straits. Something
that can close the channel down for months.
Since the Sethu-samudram channel project
is creating another narrow channel through
the Palk Strait, it can be a potential
target and is bound to interest terrorist
organizations," said B. Raman, former
head of counter terrorism at India's intelligence
agency, the Research and Analysis Wing.
|
|